Of all of the telephones launched in 2024, I do not suppose anybody would’ve predicted that the iPhone 16 would lead the trade within the sheer quantity of buttons plastered throughout a tool. Whereas Android telephones have principally deserted shortcut keys, Apple has added not one, however two new buttons to the iPhone since its 2023 refresh. In the meantime, most mainstream Android units have caught to a easy mixture of energy and quantity buttons, leaving bodily shortcuts to the corporate that beforehand thought-about dropping these {hardware} keys altogether.
The factor is, I do not suppose Apple has accomplished a very spectacular job including new buttons to the iPhone, leaving an area for its closest rivals to enhance and refine what are two good ideas in concept. The truth is, I believe there’s loads of area for an Android OEM to take up the mantle and present Apple the way it’s accomplished, all by referring again to legacy merchandise from years in the past.
The iPhone 16’s buttons are fairly lame in apply
Concurrently an excessive amount of and too little management
If you happen to’ve utterly eliminated your self from the Apple hype cycle — and seeing as you are studying an Android-centric web site proper now, that is completely truthful — the complete iPhone 16 collection comprises two buttons which are each comparatively new additions. Each are, on paper, intelligent concepts that exist to fulfill the ability customers amongst us. In apply, nevertheless, I discovered every of them fairly disappointing, and for fully opposing causes.
The Motion button first arrived on the iPhone 15 Professional and Professional Max in 2023, earlier than making its method to all 4 iPhone 16 fashions earlier this 12 months. This button is able to performing a single programmable process via an extended press, with its performance decided both in the course of the preliminary setup part or from the settings menu. You are able to do issues like toggle in your flashlight, determine music with Shazam, run a Siri Shortcut, or allow silent mode, with the latter emulating the mute swap it changed.
The issue with the Motion button is flexibility. There isn’t any method to carry out a number of duties, no possibility for double or single faucets. You might be restricted to 1 motion at a time, it doesn’t matter what you choose. Contemplating iOS 18 got here and went with none modifications to this conduct — and in contrast to on Android, there is not any manner for third-party apps to simply take management of this software — do not count on these limitations to vary any time quickly.
Then there’s Digital camera Management. Apple’s newest button skipped the same old 12 months’s price of Professional exclusivity, arriving on all 4 iPhone 16 fashions concurrently in September. This secret is each mechanical and capability, permitting for fast entry to the digital camera via both a single or double-tap (relying on whether or not the show is already turned on). As soon as within the viewfinder, you’ll be able to half-click to focus or modify picture settings like publicity and full-click to snap a shot.
In contrast to the Motion button, Digital camera Management is crammed to the brim with options, but fails so as to add something past what the touchscreen gives. Swiping via picture settings utilizing an actual button is, in concept, an excellent thought, one impressed by the kinds of devoted cameras smartphones have largely changed within the mainstream. Sadly, it is each too advanced and too restrictive to actually add something to the photo-taking expertise — in practically each case, you are higher off simply tapping on the show.
Bodily shortcuts have an extended, diversified historical past on Android
And it is time to lean again into these examples
Clearly, I believe Apple’s present assortment of {hardware} keys is surprisingly flawed, however that does not imply I hate the concept of additional buttons on its face. The iPhone’s Motion button and Digital camera Management pave the best way for the main Android corporations — Google, Samsung, and Motorola amongst them — to think about including new buttons to their respective smartphones. The truth is, I have been yelling about this for over a 12 months now, and the addition of yet one more middling button on the iPhone has pushed me to double down.
There is a lengthy, lengthy historical past of {hardware} buttons and different bodily shortcuts on Android, one too detailed to totally lay out in a chunk like this. Motorola’s 2023 ThinkPhone stored a customizable shortcut key round, however the firm ditched it on its upcoming (and, on paper, disappointing) successor. Samsung’s Bixby button began life as bodily entry to everybody’s seventh-favorite digital assistant, earlier than ultimately turning into a extra commonplace customizable management. It did not survive the flip of the last decade, or Samsung’s shifting consideration.
Not each instance is so apparent. OnePlus telephones have by no means strayed away from a reasonably commonplace button structure, however a three-way alert slider has lengthy given its person base a fast and straightforward method to toggle between ringer modes — or, on the OnePlus Open Apex Version, the flexibility to allow a reasonably ineffective VIP Mode. After which there’s Google, which has employed every thing from squeezable sides (a surprisingly helpful utility again within the Pixel 2 days, when you ask me) to tappable again glass, a software Snapchat continues to attempt to persuade me into utilizing to today.
Don’t be concerned, Sony followers — I have never forgotten you. Whereas Apple assuredly hopes you consider Digital camera Management as yet one more modern push into the longer term, AP readers know all too nicely {that a} bodily shutter button is a trademark of the niche-yet-beloved Xperia collection. And none of this even takes into consideration the earliest days of Android, the place QWERTY keyboards and bodily navigation buttons dominated the land. If you happen to’re a fan of bodily controls, you did not understand how good you had it.
Buttons needs to be concurrently highly effective and customizable
And solely Android telephone makers know easy methods to strike the fitting stability
I do not convey up these examples to make some form of level about Apple’s sense of innovation (or lack thereof) in its present {hardware}. Moderately, I believe an urge for food for shortcut keys, shutter buttons, and different bodily, tactile controls nonetheless exists, and it is excessive time Android OEMs lean into it. Apple’s lackluster strategy to buttons has left an enormous hole for corporations like Google and Samsung to return this performance to their smartphones. I hope they take it up.
Lately, telephone makers are attempting to remodel your smartphone into the equal of a laptop computer, whether or not it is via the sheer efficiency of the chip that powers it or an enormous show able to folding right into a pocketable type issue. It is excessive time for these producers to lean into this energy person fantasy, somewhat than making an attempt to drive each motion into an on-display button or gesture.
Take Circle to Search, for instance. Google determined to cover its newest try at making Lens a factor behind a long-press of the gesture bar. However on units just like the Galaxy Z Fold 6, this motion already achieved one thing — hiding the taskbar — and now, I discover myself triggering it unintentionally on a regular basis. Likewise, Gemini is locked behind long-presses of the ability button, like Assistant earlier than it. I am unable to assist to wonder if I might get extra use out of a devoted key, particularly if it supported shortly activating Gemini Dwell. Or, shying away from AI, why not implement a devoted desktop mode key for foldables and tablets? Think about if DeX mode on the Galaxy Tab S10+ may fireplace up with only a long-press of a selected button?
On the finish of the day, Android is constructed to be a platform that works finest when it is centered round customizability and personalization. I am unable to consider a greater method to ship these two parts to followers than by reintroducing extra {hardware} buttons on future telephones. And whereas I’ve listed just a few examples above, I wish to stress that these are simply that: examples. In my excellent world, the probabilities of any further buttons on Android telephones can be left fully as much as customers.
Whether or not it is a shortcut key able to performing one in all a number of routine duties — turning on the flashlight, activating do-not-disturb — or a digital camera button designed to emulate a point-and-shoot, bringing again bodily keys can solely ship a extra sturdy expertise for Android followers. So long as corporations like Samsung and Google study from Apple’s shortcomings, that’s.
Associated